Sell My Jewelry: A Complete Guide

Selling a valuable item shouldn't end in regret. Yet, many people make common mistakes, like accepting the first offer they receive, not getting a professional appraisal, or overlooking hidden fees on online platforms. These missteps can cost you hundreds or even thousands of dollars. If you’re thinking, "I want to sell my jewelry and feel good about the outcome," then you need a clear strategy. This guide is your playbook for avoiding those costly errors. We’ll cover everything from researching buyers to understanding the fine print, ensuring you can approach the sale with confidence and walk away with the best possible price.

Key Takeaways

• Know Your Jewelry's Worth Before You Sell

  : Getting a professional appraisal is the most important first step. It provides an accurate, unbiased valuation so you can negotiate effectively and avoid selling for less than your piece is worth.

• Choose the Right Sales Channel for Your Needs

  : A local specialist offers a fast, secure transaction, while online platforms provide a wider reach. Match your jewelry and your personal goals—like speed or highest price—to the right type of buyer.

• Compare Offers and Prioritize a Secure Transaction

  : Always get quotes from several buyers to ensure a competitive price. Look for transparent terms, secure payment methods, and a professional process to protect yourself and your valuables.

Where Should I Sell My Jewelry?

Deciding where to sell your jewelry can feel overwhelming, but it really comes down to what you value most: the highest price, a quick sale, or convenience. Each option has its own set of pros and cons, and understanding them will help you choose the right path for your specific pieces. Whether you have a vintage diamond ring, a designer watch, or a simple gold chain, there’s a perfect buyer out there for you.

The key is to match your item and your personal needs with the right sales channel. A local, trusted buyer might offer you the best price and immediate payment for a classic gold bracelet, while a rare antique necklace could fetch a higher price at an auction house, even if it takes longer. Let’s walk through the most common places to sell your jewelry so you can make a decision that feels right for you.

Selling to Local Jewelry Buyers

For many people, selling to a local, specialized jewelry buyer is the best choice. These experts have a deep understanding of gems, precious metals, and current market values, which means they can often offer you the most money for your items. Unlike generalists, they appreciate the fine details that determine a piece’s true worth. The process is also straightforward and secure—you get a face-to-face appraisal from a professional, receive a firm offer, and can often walk out with payment the same day. This option is ideal if you want a fair price without the complexities and delays of selling online or at auction.

Using Online Platforms and Marketplaces

If you prefer the convenience of selling from home, online platforms can connect you with a massive audience of potential buyers. Websites like Worthy specialize in auctioning diamond jewelry and watches to a network of professional buyers, while marketplaces like eBay or Etsy let you set your own price. While you can reach more people, this route comes with its own challenges. You’ll need to take high-quality photos, write compelling descriptions, and safely ship your items. You’ll also have to account for platform fees and commissions, which can cut into your final profit. It’s a great option for unique pieces, but it requires more effort on your part.

Going Through Auction Houses

If you own a particularly rare, high-value, or signed designer piece, an auction house might be your best bet. Major auction houses have a global clientele of serious collectors willing to pay top dollar for exceptional items. The competitive bidding environment can drive the price far beyond what you might get elsewhere. However, this process is also the longest and most expensive. Auction houses charge significant commissions, and it can take months from consignment to final sale. Many allow you to set a reserve price, ensuring your item won’t sell for less than your minimum, but there’s no guarantee it will sell at all.

Visiting Pawn Shops

Pawn shops offer the fastest way to get cash for your jewelry, but that speed comes at a cost. While they will buy your items, they typically offer significantly lower prices than specialized jewelry buyers. Their business model is based on providing quick loans and reselling a wide variety of goods, so they aren’t jewelry experts. They price items low to ensure they can make a profit quickly. A pawn shop might be a viable option if you need money immediately and aren’t concerned with getting the full value of your piece. For anything of significant value, however, you’ll almost always get a better offer from a dedicated jewelry buyer.

Get to Know Your Jewelry Buyer Options

When you decide to sell your jewelry, you'll find there are several paths you can take. The best one for you really depends on what you're selling, how quickly you need the money, and how hands-on you want to be. You could walk into a local shop and get an offer on the spot, or you could list your piece online and manage the sale yourself. Each option has its own set of pros and cons, and understanding them is the first step to getting a price you’re happy with.

Working with a specialist buyer often means a faster, more straightforward process with an expert who truly understands the value of your items. This is great for high-value pieces or when you want a quick, secure transaction. Traditional jewelers also have deep market knowledge and can be a convenient local option. On the other hand, online marketplaces can connect you with a massive audience of potential buyers, but they require more effort on your part, from taking photos to handling shipping and dealing with platform fees. Then there are estate buyers, who are perfect for larger collections. Let's walk through what each of these options looks like so you can make a choice that feels right for you and your jewelry.

A Specialist Buyer: Signature Gold Loans

A specialist buyer is a business that focuses exclusively on purchasing fine jewelry, diamonds, watches, and other precious items. Unlike a general pawn shop or a jeweler who is primarily focused on retail, a specialist’s main business is buying. This is our world at Signature Gold Loans. With over 35 years of experience, our family-owned business has GIA-trained experts on staff who can accurately assess your pieces and provide an immediate, fair-market offer. This route is ideal if you value expertise, transparency, and a quick, secure transaction without the hassle of finding a private buyer. You get professional service and immediate payment from a trusted local expert.

Traditional Jewelers

Taking your jewelry to a traditional retail jeweler is another solid option. These are the stores you see in your local shopping district that sell new jewelry. Many of them also buy pre-owned pieces, either to resell in their estate collection or to repurpose the materials. Because they are in the business, they have a good understanding of jewelry quality and market prices. They can often make you a fair offer, though sometimes it might be in the form of store credit rather than cash. It’s always a good idea to ask what their process is and whether they specialize in the type of jewelry you’re selling.

Online Marketplaces

If you’re comfortable managing the sales process yourself, online marketplaces open up a global audience. This can sometimes lead to a higher selling price, but it comes with more responsibilities. You’ll need to take high-quality photos, write compelling descriptions, and handle shipping and customer questions. You’ll also need to be aware of platform fees, which can cut into your final profit. Each platform caters to a slightly different audience, so it’s important to choose the one that best fits your item.

Worthy

Worthy is an online auction platform specifically for diamond jewelry and luxury watches. They handle the GIA grading, professional photography, and listing for you. Your item is then auctioned to a network of professional buyers, which can help you get a competitive price.

The RealReal

As a luxury consignment marketplace, The RealReal is a great option for authenticated designer jewelry from brands like Cartier, Tiffany & Co., and Van Cleef & Arpels. They authenticate every item, which builds trust with buyers, but they do take a significant commission from the sale.

eBay

The original online marketplace, eBay gives you access to a huge number of potential buyers. You have full control over your listing and pricing, but you’re also responsible for everything. Success on eBay requires a well-crafted listing and a good seller reputation.

1stDibs

If you're selling a high-end, rare, or antique piece, 1stDibs is a curated marketplace that connects sellers with serious collectors and affluent buyers. The vetting process for sellers is strict, ensuring a high standard of quality across the site.

Etsy

Known for handmade and vintage goods, Etsy is the perfect platform for unique, artisanal, or antique jewelry. If your piece has a distinct style or story, it can find an appreciative audience here among buyers looking for something special.

Facebook Marketplace

For a quick, local sale, Facebook Marketplace is a convenient option. It’s best for lower-priced items, as you’ll be meeting buyers in person. While it’s fast and free, be prepared for some haggling and always prioritize your safety when arranging a meetup.

Estate Buyers

Estate buyers are professionals who specialize in purchasing jewelry and other valuables from an estate. This is an excellent option if you’ve inherited a collection of items and aren’t sure where to begin. An estate buyer can assess everything at once—from fine jewelry and watches to silverware and antiques—and make a single, comprehensive offer. They understand the nuances of vintage and antique pieces and can provide a fair market valuation for the entire lot, simplifying what can often be an overwhelming process for families.

What Determines Your Jewelry's Value?

It’s easy to attach sentimental value to a piece of jewelry, but its market value is a different story. When you decide to sell, buyers look at a specific set of factors to determine what your item is worth. Understanding these elements will help you set realistic expectations and feel confident that you’re getting a fair price. While a piece might be priceless to you, its resale value is based on tangible qualities like its materials, craftsmanship, and current market desirability.

An expert evaluation is the only way to know for sure what your jewelry is worth, as its condition and the quality of its components play a huge role. Without an accurate assessment, you risk selling your pieces for much less than they’re worth. Let’s walk through the key factors that professional buyers, like our team at Signature Gold Loans, consider when making an offer. Knowing what goes into a valuation will prepare you for the selling process and help you understand the offers you receive.

Metal Type and Purity

The foundation of your jewelry's value often lies in the precious metal it’s made from. Gold, platinum, and silver are the most common, and their value is directly tied to the daily fluctuations of the global commodities market. The purity of the metal is just as important as the type. For gold, this is measured in karats. A 24-karat piece is pure gold, while an 18-karat piece is 75% gold mixed with other alloys. The higher the karat, the more valuable the metal content. You can often find the purity stamped on the jewelry itself, like "14k" or "925" for sterling silver.

Gemstone Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat

If your jewelry features gemstones, especially diamonds, their quality is assessed using the "Four Cs." These are the universal standards for grading gems and have a major impact on value.

• Cut:

  This refers to how well a stone’s facets interact with light, not its shape. A well-cut gem will have brilliant sparkle.

• Color:

  For diamonds, value is often based on the absence of color. For other gems, like sapphires or rubies, vibrant and rich color is prized.

• Clarity:

  This grades the absence of internal flaws (inclusions) or external blemishes. The fewer flaws, the more valuable the stone.

• Carat:

  This is the weight of the gemstone. While a larger carat weight generally increases value, it’s the combination of all Four Cs that determines the final price.

Brand and Designer Name

Is your piece from a well-known designer like Cartier, Tiffany & Co., or Van Cleef & Arpels? If so, its value could be significantly higher than its material worth alone. Signed pieces from luxury brands carry a premium because of their reputation for superior craftsmanship, design, and prestige. These items are highly sought after in the secondary market. If you have the original box, receipt, or certificate of authenticity, be sure to bring it with you. This documentation helps verify the piece's provenance and can substantially increase the offer you receive from a knowledgeable buyer who recognizes its brand equity.

Age and Overall Condition

The age and condition of your jewelry are critical factors. A piece that is genuinely antique (over 100 years old) or from a desirable vintage era like Art Deco or Mid-Century Modern can be very valuable due to its rarity and historical significance. However, its condition is paramount. A buyer will carefully inspect for signs of wear, damage like chips or scratches, missing stones, or faulty clasps. Any necessary repairs will likely be deducted from the offer. In some cases, if a piece is heavily damaged or outdated, its value may be limited to the "melt value" of its precious metals.

Current Market Demand

Like fashion, jewelry styles go through trends. The current market demand for certain designers, eras, or types of gems can influence your jewelry's value. For example, yellow gold might be more popular today than it was a decade ago, which can affect the price a buyer is willing to pay. It’s important to remember that the price you think your jewelry is worth might not match what buyers are currently paying. An experienced jewelry buyer has their finger on the pulse of the market and can provide an offer that reflects what your piece is truly worth today.

Appraisals and Documentation

Having official paperwork for your jewelry is always a plus. This includes any original sales receipts, diamond or gemstone grading reports (like those from GIA), and formal appraisals. An appraisal is a document that typically states the retail replacement value of an item, which is what it would cost to buy it new for insurance purposes. While this value is usually higher than a resale offer, an appraisal provides a detailed, professional description of your jewelry that is incredibly useful for a buyer. It confirms the quality of your metals and gemstones, making the valuation process more transparent and straightforward.

How to Prepare Your Jewelry for Sale

Putting a little time into preparing your jewelry before you sell it can significantly impact the offers you receive. Think of it like staging a home—you want to present your pieces in the best possible light to show off their true value. When a buyer sees that an item has been well-maintained, it builds trust and confidence in the quality of what you’re selling. Walking through these simple steps will help you organize your items, understand their worth, and approach the selling process with a clear advantage. It’s about making sure you have all the information you need to secure a fair and satisfying price for your treasured pieces.

Get a Professional Appraisal

Before you do anything else, get a professional appraisal. This is the single most important step in understanding what your jewelry is actually worth. Without an accurate assessment from a certified expert, you’re essentially guessing at the value, which could lead you to accept a much lower offer than you deserve. An appraisal provides a detailed report on your item, including its materials, gemstone quality, craftsmanship, and current market value. This document is your foundation for negotiation, giving you a credible, unbiased valuation to work from. It empowers you to enter conversations with buyers confidently, knowing you have the facts to back up your asking price.

Have It Professionally Cleaned

You wouldn’t sell a car without washing it first, and the same principle applies to jewelry. Over time, pieces accumulate dust, oils, and grime that can dull their sparkle and hide their intricate details. While you can do some light cleaning at home, a professional cleaning is the safest and most effective option, especially for delicate antiques or items with porous gemstones. A professional jeweler has the right tools and expertise to restore your piece’s original brilliance without causing any damage. A clean, gleaming piece of jewelry looks more attractive and valuable, making a much stronger first impression on potential buyers and showing that it has been handled with care.

Take High-Quality Photos

Even if you plan to sell your jewelry in person, taking high-quality photos is a smart move. Clear, well-lit images serve as a personal record and are useful for insurance purposes. If you decide to explore online options, great photos are non-negotiable. Use a simple, neutral background—like a white or black cloth—and natural daylight to capture your jewelry’s best features. Take shots from multiple angles, including close-ups of any hallmarks, designer signatures, or unique details. This visual documentation helps buyers appreciate the craftsmanship and condition of your piece before they even see it in person, and it demonstrates a high level of care on your part.

Write a Clear, Compelling Description

Knowing the story behind your jewelry can help you communicate its value. Take some time to write down everything you know about each piece. What is it made of? Are there specific gemstones? Do you know the designer or the era it comes from? If it’s an heirloom, what is its history? Crafting a detailed description helps you organize your thoughts and present the item accurately. This information creates a richer narrative, allowing a buyer to appreciate not just the materials but also the history and artistry of the piece. An engaging and informative description can build a stronger connection and highlight the unique qualities that make your jewelry special.

Set a Competitive Price

Your professional appraisal gives you an idea of the retail or insurance value, but the selling price will depend on the current market. Do some research to see what similar pieces are selling for. Look at online marketplaces and local buyer websites to get a feel for going rates. It’s a common mistake to price items based only on the cost of their materials, forgetting to account for design, brand recognition, and craftsmanship. Setting a realistic and competitive price from the start shows buyers you’re serious and knowledgeable. It also gives you a solid starting point for negotiations, ensuring you don’t undervalue your piece or price it out of the market.

Gather Your Documentation

Finally, pull together all the paperwork related to your jewelry. This includes the professional appraisal you just obtained, any original sales receipts, and certificates of authenticity, such as a report from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) for a diamond. If you have the original box or packaging, get that too. Presenting a complete package of documentation proves the item’s provenance and quality, which builds immense trust with a buyer. This level of organization and transparency can often lead to better offers, as it removes any doubt about the jewelry’s legitimacy and value. It shows you’re a responsible owner and makes the entire transaction smoother for everyone involved.

How to Get the Best Possible Price

Selling a piece of jewelry is often more than just a transaction; it can be an emotional process. You want to feel confident that you’re getting a price that truly reflects its value. The key isn't just finding a buyer, but finding the right buyer and approaching the sale with a clear strategy. Getting the best price comes down to a little bit of homework and a lot of smart decision-making. By researching the market, comparing your options, and understanding all the costs involved, you can walk away from the sale feeling satisfied and fairly compensated. Let’s walk through the essential steps to make sure you get the most for your valuables.

Research Current Market Rates

Before you even think about selling, it’s important to get a handle on what your jewelry might be worth. It’s easy to attach sentimental value to a piece, but the market value is based on tangible factors. Start by looking up the current spot price of precious metals like gold and platinum, as this forms the baseline value for many items. For branded pieces or items with significant gemstones, see what similar jewelry is listed for on reputable online marketplaces. This initial research isn’t about making you an expert appraiser; it’s about giving you a realistic price range so you can enter negotiations with confidence and a clear head.

Compare Offers from Different Buyers

You wouldn't sell your house after getting just one offer, and the same principle applies to your valuable jewelry. The first offer you receive is rarely the best one. Take the time to get quotes from several different types of buyers, including local jewelers, specialized gold buyers, and reputable online platforms. Each will have a different business model and may value your piece differently. Presenting your item to multiple experts allows you to compare their assessments and offers. This process empowers you to choose the buyer who not only offers the highest price but also provides the best service and makes you feel the most comfortable.

Time Your Sale Strategically

If you’re not in a rush to sell, patience can pay off. The market for precious metals and diamonds fluctuates, and selling during a peak can make a significant difference in the offer you receive. Beyond market trends, consider seasonality. Demand for jewelry often rises around major holidays like Valentine's Day or Christmas, which can sometimes lead to better prices. If you can afford to wait, you might get a better price. Taking a moment to assess market conditions can be a simple yet effective way to maximize your return. A little strategic timing can turn a good offer into a great one.

Understand the Platform Fees

When you sell jewelry online, the price you see is not always the amount you receive. Online marketplaces and auction sites often have a complex structure of fees that can eat into your final payout. These can include listing fees, final value fees (a percentage of the sale price), payment processing fees, and even charges for shipping and insurance. Before you commit to a platform, read the fine print carefully and calculate your potential net earnings. Sometimes, a slightly lower offer from a local buyer with a straightforward, transparent process can leave you with more money in your pocket once all the hidden costs are accounted for.

Avoid Common Pricing Mistakes

One of the biggest mistakes sellers make is pricing their jewelry incorrectly. Some underprice their items by focusing only on the raw material costs, completely overlooking the value of craftsmanship, design, and brand recognition. This is especially true for unique, handcrafted, or designer pieces. On the other end of the spectrum, sellers can overprice items based on sentimental value or an outdated appraisal from years ago. The best way to avoid both pitfalls is to ground your expectations in current market reality. A professional appraisal can provide an objective, up-to-date valuation that helps you set a fair, competitive price from the start.

How to Sell Your Jewelry Safely and Securely

When you’re selling something as personal and valuable as jewelry, peace of mind is everything. The last thing you want is to worry about your pieces getting lost, damaged, or undervalued. Taking a few thoughtful steps can make the entire process feel safe and straightforward, ensuring you and your jewelry are protected from start to finish. Whether you decide to sell online or in person, a secure transaction comes down to working with a trustworthy buyer and understanding the process.

A reputable buyer will always prioritize transparency and security. They should be happy to answer your questions and explain their procedures for handling, appraising, and purchasing your items. From vetting potential buyers to ensuring your payment is protected, being proactive is your best strategy. Think of it as doing due diligence to protect your assets. These practices will help you identify credible professionals and steer clear of potential scams, making sure your selling experience is a positive one.

Vet Potential Buyers

Before you hand over your jewelry, do a little homework on the buyer. Start by looking for established businesses with a history in the community and positive customer feedback. A quick search for online reviews on Google or the Better Business Bureau can tell you a lot about a company’s reputation. A trustworthy buyer will have a professional presence, whether it's a physical storefront or a well-maintained website with clear contact information. Be wary of anyone who pressures you into a quick decision. A key mistake is not getting a proper appraisal, which can lead to selling for less than your jewelry's true value. A great buyer will offer a free, no-obligation appraisal to build trust.

Choose a Secure Shipping Method

If you’re selling your jewelry to an online buyer, shipping is one of the most critical steps. Never send your items in a standard envelope. Your buyer should provide a secure, insured shipping method, often through a trusted carrier like FedEx or UPS. Many online buyers will send you a free appraisal kit that includes everything you need, such as a padded envelope or box and a pre-paid, insured shipping label. This service not only protects your jewelry against loss or damage in transit but also shows that the company is professional and invested in a secure process. Always get a tracking number so you can follow your package’s journey.

Protect Your Payment

Once you’ve agreed on a price, the final step is getting paid. Reputable buyers offer secure and straightforward payment options. Common methods include direct bank transfers, company checks, or secure platforms like PayPal. You should expect to receive your payment promptly, often within 24 hours of accepting the offer. Be cautious of buyers who suggest unusual payment methods or ask for sensitive financial information that isn't necessary for the transaction. Before you consider the sale complete, make sure the funds have fully cleared in your account. The Federal Trade Commission offers helpful tips for handling online payments safely.

Consider Insurance Options

Insurance is your safety net throughout the selling process. When shipping your jewelry, confirm that the package is fully insured for its replacement value. The buyer should provide this insurance as part of their shipping kit; if they don’t, that’s a major red flag. This protects you in the rare event that the package is lost or damaged. For in-person transactions, an established buyer will have their own business insurance that covers your items while they are on their premises for an appraisal. Don’t hesitate to ask a potential buyer about their insurance coverage—a professional will have no problem providing this information.

Know the Signs of a Scam

Trust your instincts. If an offer seems too good to be true, it probably is. Scammers often use high-pressure tactics, telling you an offer is only valid for a few minutes to rush your decision. Another red flag is a buyer who offers a high price without even seeing your jewelry, only to drastically lower it once they have your item in hand. It’s important to remember that the price you think your jewelry is worth might not match what buyers are willing to pay based on current market conditions. A legitimate buyer will walk you through their valuation, explaining how they arrived at their offer. Avoid anyone with vague contact information or who is unwilling to answer your questions directly.

Making Your Final Choice

You’ve done the research, gathered your documents, and have a few potential buyers lined up. Now comes the most important part: choosing the right one. This final step is about more than just the price tag. It’s about finding a buyer who is transparent, fair, and makes you feel comfortable throughout the entire process. A trustworthy transaction gives you peace of mind and ensures you’re truly getting the best overall value for your cherished items. Before you say "yes" to any offer, take a moment to carefully review these key details. This will help you confidently select the best buyer for your jewelry and your needs.

Compare Your Final Offers

Once you have offers from a few different buyers, lay them all out. It’s tempting to jump at the highest number, but it’s important to look at the complete picture. Does one offer seem significantly higher than the others? If so, find out why. Make sure there are no hidden fees or conditions that might lower your final payout. A reputable buyer will give you a straightforward offer based on a thorough evaluation of your jewelry. Don’t be afraid to ask questions. A slightly lower offer from a trusted, local expert who pays you on the spot might be more valuable than a higher, uncertain offer from an online platform that involves shipping your items and waiting for payment.

Understand the Terms of Sale

Before you agree to anything, make sure you fully understand the terms of the sale. Are you selling your item directly to the buyer, or are they selling it on your behalf for a commission? Some online platforms operate on a commission model, meaning their fee is a percentage of the final sale price. In contrast, a direct buyer like Signature Gold Loans will make you a clear, upfront offer. Always ask for the terms in writing and read the fine print. Look for any fees related to shipping, insurance, or payment processing. A transparent buyer will have no problem explaining their process and costs, ensuring there are no surprises along the way.

Review the Payment Methods

How and when you get paid is a critical part of the deal. Ask each potential buyer what payment methods they offer. Common options include a company check, direct bank transfer, or PayPal. Consider which method you feel most comfortable and secure with. One of the biggest advantages of working with a local buyer is the speed and security of payment. Often, you can walk in with your jewelry and leave with your payment the very same day. This eliminates the uncertainty and delay that can come with mailing your valuables and waiting for a transfer to clear. Always confirm the payment details before handing over your items.

Clarify the Timeline

The timeline for selling your jewelry can vary widely depending on the buyer you choose. Selling to a local jewelry buyer is often the fastest route, with the entire transaction potentially taking less than an hour. Online marketplaces and auction houses, on the other hand, can have a much longer process. It can take several weeks from the time you ship your item to when you actually receive your money. Ask for a clear, step-by-step timeline from any buyer you’re considering. Knowing what to expect and when will help you manage your expectations and choose the option that best fits your schedule and needs.

Ask About After-Sale Support

Good communication is a sign of a professional and trustworthy buyer. You should feel comfortable asking questions at every stage of the process. Before you finalize the sale, ask who your point of contact will be and how they will keep you updated. Many reputable buyers provide clear communication, letting you know when your item has been received, when the appraisal is complete, and when your payment has been sent. Knowing you have a reliable person to speak with if you have questions or concerns provides invaluable peace of mind. This level of customer care is often a hallmark of an established, family-owned business that values its reputation.

Related Articles

• Sell Your Jewelry | Signature Gold Loans

• 11 Best Places to Sell a Watch for Top Dollar

• Find the Best Jewelry Buyers & Get Top Dollar

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the offer I received lower than my jewelry's appraisal value? This is a very common and important question. An appraisal, typically done for insurance purposes, estimates the full retail cost to replace your item with a brand new, similar piece. A buyer's offer, on the other hand, reflects the current resale market value. This price accounts for the buyer's need to cover their own business costs and still make a profit when they resell the item. Think of it like the difference between a new car's sticker price and its trade-in value.

Is it worth selling jewelry that's broken or out of style? Absolutely. Even if a piece is damaged, missing stones, or has a design that isn't currently popular, it still has intrinsic value. The precious metals, like gold or platinum, can be melted down and repurposed, and any remaining gemstones can be salvaged. While you won't get a premium for the design or craftsmanship, a professional buyer will offer you a fair price based on the weight and purity of the materials.

Do I really need the original box and paperwork to sell my jewelry? While not strictly necessary for every piece, having the original documentation and packaging can definitely increase your offer, especially for designer items from brands like Tiffany & Co. or Cartier. This paperwork proves the item's authenticity and origin, which makes it more desirable on the resale market. If you don't have them, don't worry—a good buyer can still authenticate your piece, but having the full set always helps.

What's the main advantage of selling to a specialist buyer versus an online marketplace? The biggest difference comes down to speed, security, and expertise. Selling to a local specialist means you get a face-to-face evaluation from an expert, a firm offer, and immediate payment, often in a single visit. Online marketplaces can potentially connect you with more buyers, but you're responsible for taking photos, writing descriptions, handling shipping, and paying platform fees, all of which takes time and effort with no guarantee of a sale.

How can I tell if a buyer is trustworthy? A trustworthy buyer will have a solid reputation and a professional, physical location. Look for positive online reviews and check their standing with organizations like the Better Business Bureau. They should be transparent about their evaluation process, willing to answer all your questions without pressure, and provide you with a clear, no-obligation offer. Trust your gut—if you feel rushed or uncomfortable, it's best to walk away.